Showing posts with label Computer. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Computer. Show all posts

Sunday, January 4, 2015

Third party doctrine and the expectation of privacy.



Third party doctrine and the expectation of privacy.

Information has always been of value. For instance in Classical times Caesar's public letters were distributed to the public to glorify his campaigns while his private correspondences of military plans were encrypted with the cipher that bears his name. What both have in common is they need to be handed over to another person for distribution, a third party.



When sending an electronic communication the final act of the writer is to press the send button. Normally this message will appear almost instantly at the recipient's destination. Simple. Simple that is to the user, but the framework on how this occurs is complex. The message must be dissembled under known protocols, shunted between numerous servers and then re-assembled. This process involves various different stakeholders who control the servers and email infrastructure; third-parties into whose hand the message is entrusted. From a legal perspective, what are the levels of privacy involved?

In a letter, there is both the core message and address. While the former has levels of legal protection it is the address, which can be described as metadata, which has been held to be view able by the state,
Two legal cases provide the groundwork for this in the US. In United States v. Miller (1976) during an accident response, untaxed excise material was discovered which lead to an unwarranted search on the defendant's bank records. On appeal it was held there was no "expectation of privacy" due to the commercial nature of these bank records having been created from a voluntarily interaction in the normal course of business. This was affirmed later in the context of e-communications in Smith v. Maryland (1979).This revolved around crank phone calls and the police acting to record the Defendant's dialed numbers. Again it was held that as telephone communications being part of normal business practices then these were not private. Hence it appears that any such metadata information being handed over so as to transmit to another is covered by this.

Whether this ruling will remain in place, specially in light of the recent years Snowden revelations, will be in focus in a number of cases. For instance in the US the Klayman v Obama seeks to distinguish between Maryland and that of the surveillance program by the key differentials of the technologies used and the bulk nature of the collection which are now subject to various data mining techniques and processing power that was not available during the initial rulings in the 1970s. Thus the upcoming judgment on this and other related cases will provide an interesting start to 2015.


See also:
Cellular Convergence and the Death of Privacy by Stephen B. Wicker
If the Supreme Court tackles the NSA in 2015, it’ll be one of these five cases - Ars Technica




Sunday, December 28, 2014

Non disclosure agreements (NDAs) for IT Projects.

Non disclosure agreements (NDAs) for IT Projects.

NDAs can be defined in one instance as a contract: where two parties agree to share information for a certain purpose, but restricting informational access to third parties. These act as a means to ensure the IPR of a firm are protected.


This allows a client to secure any IPRs and as well prevent too much exposure which could effect any future patent applications. This also will act to clarify who owns the copyright. Instances where NDAs should be considered are:
- where there is outsourcing for new blue-skies project work
- transfer of data into the cloud
- acting within an existing system to add in addition services.
In the latter, all aspects of the ETL cycle would be under investigation which involves the non-client party gaining considerable insight into the client's business. Hence some form of agreement is required.

What does the NDA cover: this should be both the code itself, but also the sources of the data as well as the transformed information. However one area which can be negotiated is re-use of meta-material, the processes and scripts which were used during the project i.e. if this devolves entirely to the client or can this be freely implemented in other projects.

Audits provide a means to ensure that NDA procedures are being adhered to. Elements of audit might include investigation of specific documentation or visits by vetted client personal to observe procedures. However if the terms of the audit are too broad, where the client oversees all elements of the other party's work, this would act as delay on the project. Hence some measure of balance is required.

The issue of penalties should also be considered. These would come into effect if the terms were breached. It is non-uncommon (as mentioned in Cloud Computing by Millard) for clients to seek unlimited liability for such, which for the other party is very much a show-stopper. In passing, while there are element of similarity, the NDA is not a non-compete agreement with the latter having to engage with elements of employment law.

Thus NDAs are at best a means to provide a support framework so long as it does not devolve into a strait-jacket that sabotages the work of the parties.