Showing posts with label ECHR. Show all posts
Showing posts with label ECHR. Show all posts

Sunday, November 30, 2014

Online freedom of expression : human rights and exceptions.

Online freedom of expression : human rights and exceptions.


There are numerous Human rights conventions, including the global and the regional ones. For example the UN's Declaration and that of the European Convention on Human Rights (UNDHR & ECHR).The signatory parties are obliged to respect certain restrictions on the State power to regulate certain aspects of the their citizens' behaviour. The theorist Prof. Eric Posner suggested in his book "Twilight of Human Rights" that Authoritarian states do so as it establishes a patina of respectability in the international community while the more Liberal states believe their own constitutional freedoms are equivalent to their convention obligations and regard it is a pro-forma exercise. As with any of the convention articles, there are very few absolute rights contained within. The signatory documents as well contain numerous exceptions. For instance the ECHR places express limitations in Articles 8-11.


                                                           


Thus concentrating on one of these rights: Freedom of expression. This has been held as being a right that "constitutes one of the essential freedoms foundations of a democratic society" - Handyside v UK 1976. One question though is how Freedom of expression is regulated in an online environment from the perspective of Authoritarian and Liberal Jurisdictions. In each case, other rights have been forwarded as a reason to restrict this. For instance, according to Prof. Tim Wu in "Who controls the Internet", China justifies speech restrictions with a mixture of justifications drawn from the needs of state security and that the social good requires a stable society which is the basis of a functional economy. Whilst Liberal nations may not stress the security aspect, they as well base restrictions on the need of the greater social good. As Wu mentioned, France expanded considerable resources against Yahoo to prevent Nazi related material (illegal under French law) being sold in that Country in the early days of the Internet. At a Convention level, the main case in imposing limitations of expression is Gunduz, where freedom of expression in (for instance in incitement to hatred) was upheld as this was deemed to be contra societal good.

However, as authors such as Jacobs (author of the text "European Convention on Human Rights") mentioned that there were qualifiers. One being context as per Jersild (if it were part of a media discussion) and in another if it were part of a political speech, as per Surek (albeit this was a split decision). These seem to suggest that limitation is possible in both circumstances but these would need to reach a fairly high bar for the authorities to prove that this was the case.


As well and for ECHR rights in general, the restrictions must be ones authorised by the convention and "shall not be applied from any other purpose other than those for which they have been prescribed". The conclusion from Jacob's seems to be that the court would frown on all but the narrowest restrictions on rights but this being very fact specific depending on the case. Hence there is a difficulty establishing hard and fast rules.






Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Adverse Possession and Digital Books

Land is a finite physical resource. God only created a limited amount of it. Historically, land has been linked to both social status and wealth creation. So as to ensure that that land remains used and contributes to common weal in many jurisdictions if one does not safeguard ones possession of the land, then the land's ownership rights may be transferred to another party. One means of doing so is via adverse possession. In Ireland, a good overview of how this is achieved is in the book: T. Kelly, Neighbours and the law, (Clarius Press 2012).

In essence, if Party's A land is occupied without their knowledge for 12 years by Party B, then if the formalities are followed the land ownership's rights are transferred. In the larger realm of European law, this has been judged as allowable in the ECHR judgement of Pye vs UK [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J_A_Pye_(Oxford)_Ltd_v_Graham].

Thus, if you are still with me, what is the relationship with Digital Books? This has been suggested by an interesting work, Copyright and Mass Digitization by Maurizio Borghi and Stavroula Karapapa, where the authors link how Digital works are related to unused land which does not add to the common economy. In this case, the crop is binary instead of physical:a culture's heritage. The argument goes that without an online presence, then it is possible for an authored work to be lost and thus impoverishing society at large.

Up till this year(2014) this might have seen to be an academic exercise. However this with recent European case of C-117/13 Technische Universität Darmstadt v Eugen Ulmer KG [http://curia.europa.eu/juris/documents.jsf?num=C-117/13] has proved to be of real world significance. In essence this judgement allows libraries to provide online content of works (with certain restrictions) even if the rights holder's wish to withhold position.

If one were minded of how Jurisprudential matters might have influenced this, then Judge Posner's Law and Economics would seem to be the relevant construct to study; especially in light of the Google Books saga. Thus bearing in mind the malleability of rights which states give/take on land ownership then it is unsurprising such a similar attitude has found a digital presence.