Sunday, November 9, 2014

Data Privacy at Work and Anton Piller Orders

Data Privacy at Work and Anton Piller Orders

Privacy is a right. But like a majority of such is not absolute. There are usually a slew of other rights (several hundred according to Eric Posner's "Twilight of human rights") which need be balanced. Thus at work the employer has a measured right as well to monitor employees, within a reasonable limit.



The cases of Halford v UK (1997) 24 EHRR 523 and Copland v UK (2007) 45 EHRR 37  suggest there also has to be reasonable expectation of privacy at work to balance this. So if there was a credible threat of larceny involved it would seem to be correct to monitor, provided the employees were informed clearly and in good time. This type of data is also a resource so has a measure of value: for instance if companies are being merged, then up to a certain point it would be sensible not to swap employee personal data or at least make real efforts to anonymise the records in a commercial context.

Thus from an IT perspective, how does this relate to company supplied mobile devices such as smart phones? The data found within these, both in internal or external storage thanks to Moore's law, is always expanding. Even if no personal data or apps were permitted, the fact that geo-location data is captured during non-core office hours means not only is personal data being stored, but the protected class known as sensitive data could be viewed by employers. For instance, that an employee is going to a specialist doctor or at a rival's place of business would not be facts that the employee would wish to share.

These are not the only non-state actor that could view the personal data. There is the civil search warrant present in Common law countries known as the Anton Piller order. This is basically a search and seize order. This has been called the "Stealthbomber" of litigation. However, given that Data Protection is of EU Directive origin, would suggest that such orders need to modified to respect the personal information of the employee.
If there were to be shown the existence of procedural problems with the safety of this data, this would call into question the proportionality of any such order and would likely result in the designated Data Protection office becoming involved. The adverse publicity and possible fines could then apply as core individual EU rights are not lightly breached.


Sunday, November 2, 2014

Book Review: The Master Switch

The Master Switch: The Rise and Fall of Information Empires by Tim Wu



This was published in 2011 and finally got around to reading it. The key idea behind this work echoes the concept of the “Creative Destruction” cycle in innovation. This was first posited by the Austrian economist Joseph Schumpeter: "process of industrial mutation that incessantly revolutionizes the economic structure from within, incessantly destroying the old one, incessantly creating a new one." - link.

In this book, Mr. Wu provides a legal/historical/technological context so as to show how this has effected both the development of innovation in the IT sector (e.g. Telegraph vs Telephones) as well as how this cycle is still in play in the modern digital era. So that small companies challenge a traditional service provider, with one emerging to take the elder's place (the Kronos effect) and in turns has to defend its new position against fresh newer challengers' innovations.

What seems to be missing is the grand sense of public service that motivated the early monopolists such as Bell's Vail, and instead the action to regulate the modern web is driven by an attempt to lock-in industrial power of past gains, such as present in the Copyright lobby.

Overall a well constructed, crafted read which places current innovations in context.


Embedded Videos and copyright

Embedded Videos




The Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has recently ruled on a matter of copyright within Youtube videos. BestWater International Case (C-348/13). A German court relying on the EU power to seek the CJEU guidance on EU legal matters referred it. The material facts were that the applicant objected that two rival contractors had linked embedded youtube material from the applicant without permission on the rival's website


The legal question was
“
Does the embedding, within one’s own website, of another person’s work made available to the public on a third-party website, in circumstances such as those in the main proceedings, constitute communication to the public within the meaning of Article 3(1) of Directive 2001/29/EC, 1 even where that other person’s work is not thereby communicated to a new public and the communication of the work does not use a specific technical means which differs from that of the original communication?”


Result: Embedding a Youtube video on a 3rd party site is not an infringement of copyright.


Context:
Taking a definition of copyright as “ that is is an identifier placed on works to inform the world of ownership”- “Fashion Law” by Ursula Furi-Perry.

My own understanding of embedding would be to hyperlink to another web-location and allow content, in this case a video, to be played.

Of interest: EU Copyright directive can be found here: http://eur-lex.europa.eu/legal-content/EN/ALL/?uri=CELEX:32001L0029

Currently the judgement is only in German.
Ich kann nicht sprechen gut Deutsch : http://www.scribd.com/doc/244360017/EuGH-C-348-13-Framing (auf Deutesh) So my understanding is sparse, to say the least.

Comment:
So to peek beneath the surface of this ruling there are always a number of factors which influence the outcome: both the explicit ones of both public policy reasons for the “social good” and as part of the foundation impetus of the EU to boost trade as well as factors, borrowed from Posner's law and economics, on how well the embedded stakeholders have managed to lobbied so as to have their world view taken as the normative scenario. However, based on the outcome it seems common sense has prevailed.


Long term, what will be the fallout? i.e. does the rather overused term landmark belong to this.

Overall a cautious welcome. While it is rather trite at this stage to state that “Information wants to be free”, it can hardly be said that material on Youtube is out of the way. The material was in no way illegal uploaded onto the site or illegally kept their by the site's owners.

In fact, the ability to disable embedding was present.
“
If you've uploaded a video and do not want to allow others to embed your video on external sites, here's how to disable the option:
Visit your Video Manager.
Find the video you'd like to change and click Edit.
Click Advanced Settings under the video.
Uncheck the Allow Embedding checkbox under the "Distribution Options" section.
Click Save changes at the bottom of the page.


Hence overkill. De minimus non curat lex, and this is rather an excellent reason for this to be followed. Thus the speed which the court dealt with this can be commended.


Interesting other view on this:
“The CJEU Continues to be the Court of Common Sense: The BestWater Case Ruling or Another Good Day for the Internet” -link.


Sunday, October 26, 2014

Has Data Protection gone a step too far in Europe?


Data protection is very much part and parcel of the human rights driven approach that the EU has taken for personal data. Leaving aside the rather broad exceptions that are present for the state when it comes to gathering information on people when it comes to revenue and taxes (under section 8 of the Data Directive 1995) this is broadly a positive step. However as the saying goes, too much of a good intention can lead inter alia to a poor outcome. In this case, the use of data to better serve customer needs being waylaid.



This has in part been prompted by the reading of the book, What Stays in Vegas: The World of Personal Data by Adam Tanner. Here there are numerous negative examples of how Big Data and how the prevalence of digitization has lead to personal data being used for morally questionable outcomes. For instance the use of criminal mugshots in websites for the titillation of the general populace would likely give a typical Data Protection commissioner fits. This is very much in keeping with the commercial driven agenda where the worth of the data is key to understanding how the US crafts their rather minimalist data protection laws.

On the other hand, where commercial interests are present so too are the technological innovation that goes hand in hand with such. Key to this was the paper, written in part by CEO of a Vegas Corp. Gary Loveman, "Putting the Service-Profit Chain to Work" which traces the importance of the regular customer. Whilst he/she in an average transaction might not spend much, a satisfied customer in their lifetime would be the sum total of their entire spending and as such would be equivalent to the occasional bigger spender. This insight lead to more emphasis on data gathering on these heretofore unremarked segments of the market place and the use of Big data to better craft personalised products to keep them as regular spenders. As Tanner in his book mentions in the context of gathering this data, there is a market imperative to keep much of this open and voluntary as even the suggestion of "creepiness" would lose the client and perhaps draw the ire of the legislators. As well in parallel, this drives the technological innovation of Big data.


Thus while not saying their should be a whole scale rollback of the EU data protection, given that the current directive is being overhauled to make it fit for the Cloud/Big Data purpose, it would be relevant to note that the societal good can as well be serviced by for-profit motivations.

Thursday, October 23, 2014

Book Review:Copyright and Mass Digitization by Borghi & Karapapa

This book deals with how analogue works, such as paper books, are transferred onto the digital realm en mass.

Copyright and Mass Digitization

The context is mostly within the EU (especially referencing the European Copyright Directive ) but also investigates the US concept of "Fair use". The authors provide an excellent overview of the differing bundles of rights associated with copyright and how this is evolving in terms of reaction to societal and technological shifts. Key is the bulk digitisation efforts by commercial and non-profits and how this effects authors both known and unknown (ie orphan works). This is in parallel to developments in the area of Big Data, where for instance new discoveries could be made by data mining connections between various online resources such as scientific papers.

Overall a good introduction to this interesting intersection of law and IT.

Wednesday, October 22, 2014

Adverse Possession and Digital Books

Land is a finite physical resource. God only created a limited amount of it. Historically, land has been linked to both social status and wealth creation. So as to ensure that that land remains used and contributes to common weal in many jurisdictions if one does not safeguard ones possession of the land, then the land's ownership rights may be transferred to another party. One means of doing so is via adverse possession. In Ireland, a good overview of how this is achieved is in the book: T. Kelly, Neighbours and the law, (Clarius Press 2012).

In essence, if Party's A land is occupied without their knowledge for 12 years by Party B, then if the formalities are followed the land ownership's rights are transferred. In the larger realm of European law, this has been judged as allowable in the ECHR judgement of Pye vs UK [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/J_A_Pye_(Oxford)_Ltd_v_Graham].

Thus, if you are still with me, what is the relationship with Digital Books? This has been suggested by an interesting work, Copyright and Mass Digitization by Maurizio Borghi and Stavroula Karapapa, where the authors link how Digital works are related to unused land which does not add to the common economy. In this case, the crop is binary instead of physical:a culture's heritage. The argument goes that without an online presence, then it is possible for an authored work to be lost and thus impoverishing society at large.

Up till this year(2014) this might have seen to be an academic exercise. However this with recent European case of C-117/13 Technische Universität Darmstadt v Eugen Ulmer KG [http://curia.europa.eu/juris/documents.jsf?num=C-117/13] has proved to be of real world significance. In essence this judgement allows libraries to provide online content of works (with certain restrictions) even if the rights holder's wish to withhold position.

If one were minded of how Jurisprudential matters might have influenced this, then Judge Posner's Law and Economics would seem to be the relevant construct to study; especially in light of the Google Books saga. Thus bearing in mind the malleability of rights which states give/take on land ownership then it is unsurprising such a similar attitude has found a digital presence.

Tuesday, October 21, 2014

Case of Cartier, Montblanc and Richemont v BSkyB, BT, TalkTalk, EE and Virgin


The case of Cartier, Montblanc and Richemont v BSkyB, BT, TalkTalk, EE and Virgin (Open Rights Group intervening) [2014] EWHC 3354  deals with the Claimants Intellectual rights holder seeking to force the Defendants ISPs to block various websites that the Claimants indicate are hosting and selling counterfeit goods. An excellent summary of the background of this is found in the IPKat site [http://ipkitten.blogspot.ie/2014/10/online-enforcement-has-colour-and-name.html] as well the judgement on Bailli [http://www.bailii.org/cgi-bin/markup.cgi?doc=/ew/cases/EWHC/Ch/2003/3354.html&query=Cartier&method=boolean].
The summary is that with some caveats the rights holder is allowed under various legal provisions (domestic and EU) to apply for a blocking injunction. The upshot is that the offending sites can be blocked.


The Ancient Greeks had a phrase, men/de translated roughly as on the one hand and on the other.
Thus stealing has been perceived as a wrong doing since Biblical times. There are numerous and many laws on the subject of in both common and criminal law both on the direct action of stealing and the surrounding activities: from supply of house breaking tools to that of selling counterfeit goods on a newspaper (a paper based media of information exchange). So the latter example seems to be analogous close to a website allegedly selling similar goods and viewable via the ISPs network. However to differential, that while the Cartier judgment thankfully provides a sunset clause (with two years being suggested) it ignores the social,economic and IT framework that websites in general operate in. A vast majority of sites are both legitimate and their underlying software can be changed so as to restrict content on site. This coupled with the fact that sites have a value, with site names being auctioned depending on their worth means than any injunction, even if justified, can impact the sites owners. Furthermore there is an economic disparity between the power dynamic between corporate rights holder and site owners. From examples of how other take-down notices by rights agencies have been automated [https://www.techdirt.com/articles/20120308/03505018034/eff-argues-that-automated-bogus-dmca-takedowns-violate-law-are-subject-to-sanctions.shtml] so as to be overlying broad and having a censorious effect, then over eager use of injunction could have the same effect on the EU freedom of selling goods.


Therefore while counterfeiting is a problem that deserves solution, it should be a nuanced one that those not effect the rights and open innovative flow of data that rights holders themselves have used to sell their products.